Kangra: The new Government of Himachal Pradesh and the Chief Minister Jai Ram Thakur were ridiculed for allegedly playing “politics of paying tribute” over the dead bodies of 23 children killed in the school bus accident near Nurpur in Kangra on April 9, 2018.
The Chief Minister also faced the wrath of the public on social media. The people termed it as the “most degraded level” of politics that the nation has ever witnessed.
This widespread criticism compelled the Deputy Commissioner of Kangra, Sandeep Kumar and the local MLA Rakesh Pathania to come out in their defence. The DC on April 12 released a media statement in which he refuted the allegations labelled against them regarding the deliberate delay in handing over the dead bodies deceased children
The DC termed it as an act of irresponsible reporting. The local MLA Rakesh Pathania also came out with an explanation and said that it was decided to transport all the bodies together to avoid inconvenience due to crowdedness.
However, the Daily, in its April 13 edition, has produced a statement of an aggrieved family member and stood by its report.
As per the daily, Gulshan, a resident of Chamba, alleged that everytime the parents asked for the body, they were told to wait for the Chief Minister’s arrival.
Meanwhile, a video of Gulshan repeating his statement has also appeared on the social media.
It is an illogical explanation of the administration that the parents of the children were not available early morning, the Daily said. All the parents had rushed to the hospital on the evening the accident took place. They waited till morning at the hospital, added the report.
In its April 11 edition, the Daily had alleged the district administration and Pathania of keeping the parents of the victims waiting for about three hours to claim the bodies.
It was further alleged by the Daily that the bodies which already handed over to the parents were also brought back so that the Chief Minister and the Union Minister JP Nadda could perform a political drama of paying tribute to the victims.
A stage was set and mike was installed for the Chief Minister, the report alleged.
As per the report, the post-mortems of the victims including four adults were completed between 7:30 AM to 8:00 AM on April 10. However, the parents were told that the Chief Minister will be arriving to distribute the cheques of the relief money, alleged the report.
When the Union Minister Nadda was asked about the incident, he denied having any knowledge regarding the delay. He said the local administration and the MLA were responsible for all the arrangement.
हिमाचल के मलकवाल, काँगड़ा में हुई स्कूल बस दुर्घटना के मृतकों को भावभीनी श्रधांजलि अर्पित की और घायलों से अस्पताल में उनका हाल-चाल जाना। pic.twitter.com/clirsBkrlg
— Jagat Prakash Nadda (@JPNadda) April 10, 2018
While the mourning parents had lined up outside the mortuary to claim the bodies, they were made to wait until the Chief Minister and Union Minister arrived at 10:30.
The daily also alleged that the DC, Kangra, and local MLA Rakes Pathania were seen directing the staff regarding Chief Minister’s reception. While there were only two nurses to look after four survived children during the previous night, all the staff along with the district administration swarmed upon next morning to receive the Chief Minister.
However, on April 12, the DC issued a press statement terming the news as false and misleading one. He said an elaborate inquiry was conducted and it was found that no delay was made deliberately. He claimed that the post-mortems were completed at 10:30 AM, and not at 7:30 AM, as alleged by the Daily.
Opposed to the allegation, the DC further claimed that no post-mortem was conducted on April 9. He said as per the rules a post-mortem should be conducted in daylight, therefore, it was not possible to hand over the bodies to the parents on April 9.
The post-mortems were conducted in the morning only in the presence of the parents and they were not available on the evening the accident took place, the DC claimed.
However, the DC did not say anything regarding legal action against the Daily for publishing such defamatory news.
If the report was, in fact, misleading, then we will be soon reading an apology published in the same Daily or a legal action by the administration. If none of the two situations appears, then it would suggest the ugly allegations made in the report were true.
Rating BJP’s performance in Shimla MC on completion of one year
Shimla: The public of Shimla town on June 20, 2017, gave the command of the Municipal Corporation to Bharatiya Janata Party for the first time in 31 years. The SMC would complete one year in the office on the coming Wednesday.
Sadly, BJP’s inexperience and choice of candidates for responsible posts of the Mayor and Deputy Mayor backfired at the party. SMC has not only failed to establish coordination with its own Ward Councilors but also with the other government departments.
The SMC couldn’t even run the House or organize its session properly. Last week, the meeting of the House was reportedly cancelled as the Ward Councilors and the Mayor wanted to avoid confrontation over the water crisis.
The situation of the town is only worsening. For instance, Shimla couldn’t find a place in top 100 cities in Swacch Bharat ranking, which was at 14 in 2014.
As a matter of fact, the monthly charges for the door-to-door garbage collection were hiked but the facility did not improve.
Shimla town not only faced loss to the hospitality industry due to recent unprecedented water-paucity but also faced embarrassment at international level as foreign media highlighted it. It was for the first time that the tourists were told to stay away from the town due to the water crisis.
On the top of it, the district administration and the SMC were not accepting that there was actually a crisis due to which public faced hardships for over two weeks and are still receiving rationed supply.
Let us take a look at some of the major promises of the BJP manifesto released before the election to the SMC in 2017. The major promises included:
- 27×4 Water Supply
- Construction of Kol Dam and revival of over 30 natural resources to connect them to the town’s water supply through pipelines
- Better sanitation facilities and making the town garbage-free by installing dustbins at various places
- Introduction of bio-dustbins in the town
- Construction of parking complexes for as many as 10,000 vehicles to cut down traffic chaos
- Construction of fly-overs, escalators, and attractive footpaths to facilitate both locals and tourists
- Construction of gyms and refreshment centres in every Ward
- Making the town stray cattle and animal free
- Other than these main resolutions, there were several other promises in the manifesto, which are not even in the picture after one year
The water crisis of Shimla town speaks of the efforts made to fulfil 24×7 water supply, while heaps of garbage at market-places and about four strikes of the Shimla Heritage, Environment, and Beautification (SEHB) workers highlights the poor sanitation condition.
The Ward Councilors, as well as the Mayor, remained in news for quarrels over tours. The Mayor left the town and flew to China on a tour amid the most severe crisis it was facing.
Now, on completion of one year, the Deputy Mayor is reportedly demanding a government vehicle while the Mayor was said to have asked for a new vehicle.
BJP’s poor performance has put it on the target of not only the oppositions but also the people.
Sanjay Chauhan, former mayor of Shimla and a prominent leader of the State Communist Party of India (Marxist), which had completed its five years term at the SMC in 2017, has termed the one year of the SMC as a complete failure.
Neither BJP could run the MC House properly, not it could uphold its dignity. The house hardly recorded any relevant discussions on matters of public interest. Rather, the Councilors were dissuaded whenever they tried to do so, said Sanjay.
For the first time in the SMC’s history, the ruling party had walked out of the House after failing to answer the questions of the Councilors, he said.
He further pointed out that no new schemes were introduced during the last one year. Instead, the MC could not make a progress of even an inch in the schemes that were already passed by the previous MC. Despite the availability of the funds, the new MC did not show any interest in the implementation of these schemes, he said.
Chauhan said the list of incomplete projects includes the Smart City project (Rs, 2806 crores), World Bank-funded Kol dam drinking water scheme (875 crores) Amrut Yojana (243 crores), Tutikandi rope-way (200 crores), Shimla beautification project (66 crores) and other such projects worth 410 cores.
Therefore, BJP-ruled SMC has failed to utilize about 4,700 crores sanctioned during the CPI (M) tenure for various schemes, he said.
The CPI (M) said it was the first time that the city witnessed such chaos over the shortage of drinking water, which has dented the popularity of the town all over the world.
Another jolt to the SMC came after the High Court and the Governor had to take the responsibility of water supply and distribution on their shoulders.
No progress has been reported in the schemes of the public interest, which were due to be completed in 2017, Sanjay alleged.
The SMC was supposed to complete the task of replacing meters by June 2017 and start issuing bills generated through meter readings, but it’s still pending in 2018, he said.
Despite the availability of adequate funds, the task of replacing water pumps and supply pipelines at Gumma and Girri schemes was not undertaken within the provided time-frame.
He further added that no efforts were made for the betterment of sewerage management in some localities like Totu despite the availability of funds.
The work of multi-purpose and modern park at the Rani Ground in Kasumpti was also expected to be completed by June 2017.
In addition to Kaithu, Dhalli, Vikasnagar, Jivaanu Colony, Kasumpti, about 55 spots were already marked for the construction of parking lots in various localities and funds were already sanctioned. However, the SMC has not even started any construction work in last one year, said Sanjay.
The construction of community buildings in Summerhill, Dhalli, Kaithu etc. is still pending despite funds. Similarly, he said, a provision of funds was made during the previous SMC for the construction of four labour hostels.
He further said the sanitation facilities in the town are in tatters for past one year. The SEHB workers went on strike for four times in one year due to the poor management of the SMC. The charges for the service of garbage collection were hiked and the salary of SEHB workers reduced.
Sanjay alleged that the SMC has handed over the contract of garbage collection to its favourite private company.
Moreover, he said, the court had to intervene during the strike of the workers, which confirms the incapability and insufficiency of the current MC.
The Mayor was most visible in local events as Chief Guest or kept herself tagged to the Chief Minister or Union Minister visits. However, she seems satisfied with her performance and told media that she did her best.
For her, the inconvenience faced by the public during the recent water scarcity was just a lie told by the oppositions and media.
The current Mayor and Deputy Mayor also faced criticism from BJP’s own Councilors. The opposition Congress had almost geared up for the dissolution of the SMC after sensing this defection within the ruling party.
Once again, it would not be wrong to conclude that there has been more politics than efforts to fulfil the promises made in the manifesto.
HP Govt’s failure in implementing FRA Act turning habitants into encroachers
The right to claim titles in “Forest” areas occupied prior to December 13, 2005, is clearly provided in the FRA for the individuals regarded as “encroachers” under the previous legal framework.
Shimla: About 1500 people participated in a rally and public meeting held on June 7, 2018, at Reckong Peo, Kinnaur, to raise their voice against on-going eviction drive that is terming a large number of occupants of forestland as illegal encroachers in complete violation of the Forest Rights Act, 2006.
The people protested against HP Government’s poor implementation of the FRA, in their district as well as in the entire state.
The rally and public meeting were organized jointly by the Him Lok Jagriti Manch, Zilla Van Adhikar Mancha, a Kinnaur-based platform, Himachal Van Adhikar Manch, Himdhara Collective, and Himalaya Niti Abhiyan.
A memorandum was submitted to the Deputy Commissioner with a demand to immediately start processing the claims under FRA from Kinnaur district.
The Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers Act, or Recognition of Forest Rights Act – commonly known as the Forest Rights Act (FRA)- was passed by Parliament in 2006 to address historical injustices and exclusion meted out to a large community of forest dwellers in India. Rights over forestlands were taken away since notification of forests under colonial Indian Forest Act (1927).
While in Himachal, there was a Forest Settlement in the 1970s that settled people’s access to forestlands, for the community, these remained privileges that could be taken away any time, the activists of organizing groups said.
Since then, a process of alienation of forest-dwelling communities has intensified in the name of development, wildlife conservation, forest management, and development, shrinking survival spaces of the forest-dependent people each time, they said.
It is only logical to assume that this piece of legislation is extremely relevant for Himachal Pradesh, where 67 percent of the total land area is under the jurisdiction of the Forest Department, the activists said.
In the initial phase, the State government had implemented the Act only in the Schedule – V (Tribal regions) areas of the State. As a result of this, the process of implementation in the State faced a long delay.
In 2013, after a High Court order and repeated instructions from the Centre, the government decided to implement the Act in non-tribal areas also. Despite the formation of more than 17503 Forest Right Committees (FRCs), which would file the claims, the process is not taking off in most areas.
Local administration and government officials have a partial understanding of the act and several misgivings. As a result of it, the process is just not moving forward.
The activists informed that it is extremely unfortunate that despite the formation of FRCs in 99.82% of revenue villages, only 53 individuals and 7 community titles have been issued under the Act in Himachal in past five years.
Further, on April 6, 2015, the Himachal Pradesh High Court ordered the removal of encroachments on “forest land” in the state within six months. It has triggered an eviction drive by the Forest Department.
This includes serving notices for removal of encroachments, disconnecting electricity and water supply provided to all “illegal” structures raised over encroached land and legal action in case of non-compliance.
In upper Shimla, the Forest Department went to the extent of felling apple trees from orchards on “forest land.” In Kinnaur, 98 such notices have been served to so-called “encroachers”.
Fearing further action, the people of Kinnaur, earlier on July 25, 2015, organised a huge rally at District headquarters, Rekong Peo, questioning the manner in which the Forest Department is implementing the orders of the High Court.
The activists emphasized on the importance of understanding the right to claim titles in “Forest” areas occupied prior to December 13, 2005, is clearly provided in the FRA for the individuals regarded as “encroachers” under the previous legal framework.
The provisions of this Act are applicable for Scheduled Tribes and other forest-dwelling communities, which mean almost the entire state. This is a special Act that supersedes all other previous acts related to forests like the Indian Forest Act 1927 or the Forest Conservation Act 1980.
It is a matter of concern that the state government failed to bring the issue of this non-implementation of the FRA Act to the attention of the High Court, the activists said.
As per the Section 5(4) of Chapter III of the FRA,
No member of a forest dwelling Scheduled Tribe or other traditional forest dwellers shall be evicted or removed from forest land under his occupation till the recognition and verification procedure is complete.
According to the 2011 Census, of the total workforce in Himachal, around 62 percents are cultivators and agricultural labourers. This means that a majority of the population dependent completely on farming and forests (livestock rearing) as a livelihood is not a beneficiary in the state budget allocations, the activists said.
Further, the falling number of jobs in the private sector has added to the crises between communities, which could ultimately lead to distress migration, visible in states like Uttarakhand, they said expressing concern.
HP Govt says schools within Shimla MC area closed for week due to high tourist footfall, not water crisis
Shimla: Himachal Pradesh Government has decided to shut-down all government schools falling within the jurisdiction of Shimla Municipal Corporation for a week.
From June 4 to June 8, all primary, middle, higher, and senior secondary schools will remain closed.
However, the interesting part the reasons given in the official notification issued by the Director of Higher Education, Dr Amar Dev on June 2.
It doesn’t include even a slight reference to the ongoing chaos over water scarcity.
As per the notification, the Higher and Primary Education of Departments, HP, has decided to announce a holiday due to higher movement of tourists during the peak tourist season.
Another reason that was cited in the notification, was that the Departments have taken this reason considering the pattern of the private schools that have already announced a summer break.
There is a condition too. The schools will not get the holidays they used to get during monsoon, which was the set pattern. The Education Minister, Suresh Bhardwaj, suggested the government might change the pattern permanently.
It’s for the first time that government schools are being given summer holidays. Shimla town has always been a popular tourist destination and the tourist footfall has always been high during the summer season,
the former Mayor of the city, Sanjay Chauhan, told Himachal Watcher.
The Government doesn’t have enough guts to admit that ongoing water crisis is a reason behind it because that would expose not only its poor response to the situation but a huge mismanagement and unfair treatment in the distribution of drinking water too,
the further added.
It appears to be an attempt to kill two birds with one stone. The hotels were forced to cancel bookings and buy water from private tankers on the very high rate. The tourist faced a lot of inconveniences and they are trying to avoid Shimla, the hoteliers have been alleging.
The registered hotels are not receiving supply from the Corporation, but hundreds of unregistered guest houses/flats that have mushroomed in residential localities illegally are consuming domestic water via tankers for commercial purpose. The registered hotels are buying water from private tankers as there is no other choice. The SMC cites High Court orders due to which the supply to hotels in the town is prohibited via SMC tankers. So, tourists are in fact facing problems, but still hotels are facilitating them at their own level,
Sanjay Sood, the President of Hotel & Restaurant Association of Northern India told HW.
So, citing a higher tourist footfall would suggest that the town is doing fine and there is only a little shortage of water but no crisis. Secondly, the Government was compelled to close the schools, as there was no water – neither for drinking nor for cooking mid-day meals and cleaning of toilets.
Does it suggest that our elected government is not being honest enough to tell the truth to its people?
Misc News/Press Release2 months ago
TCP official shot dead in Himachal’s Kasauli by hotelier during demolition drive
HW Community2 months ago
Kotkhai Gudiya case solved, says CBI claiming it was not a gang rape
Misc News/Press Release2 months ago
Kasauli shootout: Police announce Rs. 1 lakh award for tip-off on absconding accused
Misc News/Press Release2 months ago
Kasauli Shootout: SC pulls up HP Govt and Police over poor security arrangements
HW Community2 months ago
“Are IG, SP, DSP in jail to save a woodcutter?”: Unconvinced father of Gudiya asks CBI
Misc News/Press Release2 months ago
15-year-old in Palampur allegedly dragged to jungle, gang-raped while returning from temple
Environment2 months ago
Taxi operators cheer after Manali-Rohtang ‘electric bus service’ cancelled ahead of peak tourist season
HW Community2 months ago
Kasauli shootout accused arrested, SP Solan, DSP, 2 SHOs transferred, Himachal Gaurav Puraskar announced for killed officer