Yug Murder Case: Possible torture to death, drowned alive, suggests initial investigation, protest erupts in Shimla
SHIMLA- Horrific case of abduction and cold blooded murder of 4-years-old Yug Gupta in Shimla has sent a wave of shock across Himachal Pradesh – one of the most peaceful places in India. The family including two sisters aged 8 and 10 is broke.
Protest has erupted in the city as shopkeepers kept shops closed on Tuesday and marched to meet Virbhadra Singh and HP HC Chief Justice.
Preliminary Investigation Suggest Torture to Death
Himachal isn’t crime free; murders, robberies and sexual assaults do happen here, but such insanity was rarely heard before. As more details about the murder case are coming into light, the investigation is suggesting probable torture of the kid like beating, starving, and forcibly making him drink liquor before eventually killing him on June 21.
Although, it is not confirmed, but initial investigation suggest that the boy might have been thrown alive into the Municipal Corporation’s Kelestine water tank near Bharari in Shimla.
The mobile locations of the arrested men showed that Yug was hidden in a flat near Ramchandra Chowk at Navbahar. Chander had rented this flat (number HIG 22).
All Suspects Locals Including a Neighbor
All men, Tejinder Singh, Virkrant Bakshi, and Chander Sharma are locals, residents of Shimla. Chander Sharma is neighbor of Vinod Gupta, father of deceased Yug.
Four Ransom Letters
On June 27, 2014, after 14 days of abduction, the family received first ransom later demanding delivery of Rs. 3.60 crores in Ambala through hands of Vinod’s servant Hari. The letter was inserted into the Shop that Vinod owns in Ram Bazaar. The family immediately sent the servant to Ambala, but no one appeared to collect the ransom. In second letter, Rs. 4 crores were demanded, but again it was not collected by the kidnappers. In third letter, the amount of ransom was raised to 10 crores, and back to Rs. 4 crore in the fourth letter.
According to reports, after kidnapping Yug, Chander, who was studying law, came back to Ram Bazaar and connected to family members as sympathizer. He dedicatedly remained present with family and even police teams during search operations claiming to be a member of International Human Rights Commission. The family begun to trust him and shared all information regarding the plans for search of Yug.
Doubts on Chander surfaced in the minds of family members after he started showing excess interest in matters pertaining to wealth and assets of the family. He used to inquire regarding financial status of the family and relatives.
Later, the family brought this interest of Chander in their financial matters to the notice of CID. The lie detector test of Vinod’s servant had also hinted that Chander could have abducted Yug for ransom. Thereafter, CID increased surveillance and arrested Tejinder and Vikrant in June, but easily secured bail from court.
When CID asked them to take lie detector test, both avoided it stating health issues, which almost confirmed agency’s suspicion. Finally, on Sunday, CID arrested Vikrant from Chandigarh based on strong evidences and made him confess the crime and recovered details of location of the body of the boy. Following this information, CID on Monday exhumed body remains from the said Kelston water tank. Now, all three men have been detained.
CID also used handwriting samples of the suspects that were found identical to ransom letters. Other materials are being recovered from their laptops and cellphones.
Public Blame Shimla Police for Not Taking Interest
Another noticeable aspect is that the family had already given names of Tejinder and Vikrant to police as suspects and both of them also had criminal record against them. Both were found involved in a theft case in Shimla. However, Shimla Police couldn’t materialize such a strong lead at all. Rather, it was carrying one of the suspects with it almost all the time during investigation. Therefore, the case was transferred to the CID.
People Demand Death Penalty, Social Boycott of Families
Enraged hearing heinousness of culprits, people are demanding death penalty for them and made call for social boycott of their families. Protesters also asked lawyer community to boycott culprits, and to not take their case as defense lawyer.
Cleaning of MC Water Tanks in Papers only?
The High Court of Himachal Pradesh is agitated and questioning Shimla MC how it could not spot the skeleton of the boy if it really cleaned the 12 lakh litre capacity tank twice this year, in January and June. Court has questioned affidavits filed by SMC claiming cleaning and supply of drinkable water. It noticeable that this time judges colony located in the posh Kelston area were also receiving water supply from the same tank along with other VIP residences, Police Line Bharari, Bharari Bazaar, Tara Badi, Lower Bharari, and some areas of Kuftadhar.
People and some politicians have opened attack on the MC officials and has demanded action against them as well.
Taking a serious note of the issue of recovery of the skeleton from a water tank, the High Court on Tuesday sought response from the state government and directed the Investigation Officer to file detailed affidavit in this regard. A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice Mansoor Ahmad Mir and Justice Tarlok Singh Chauhan passed this order during the hearing of a PIL on the issue of contaminated water supply in Shimla city. Next hearing in the case is scheduled to be held on September 27.
No Locks on MC Water Tanks, No Provision for Security
The case clearly tells the tale of SMC’s ignorance towards security of the water tanks. The suspects were able to open it and dump the body as there was no lock on it. It implies that anyone could contaminate the water in these tanks with anything at anytime, risking lives of public.
Shimla MC’s Clarification
After news of recovery of skeleton from SMC water tank broke out, the media tried to connect to corporation officials. However, the Commissioner Pankaj Rai, Mayor Sanjay Chauhan, Engineer etc. did not respond to phone calls. But SMC’s initial clarification said that a skeleton was found earlier during cleaning but it was thrown away as workers took it to be remains of a monkey. As stark contrast to this statement, according to CID, team recovered the remains from the tank and, not from outside the tank.
SMC engineers claimed that they had cleaned not only the Keleston tank in January and June 2016, but also 23 other tanks after the jaundice outbreak.
The tanks were emptied, then were washed by chlorinated water,
the staff claimed.
It is not clear how the skeleton was recovered, but we have sought report from the municipal engineer
, said Chauhan.
The suspects are in custody and have been sent on police remand of five days. More clarity on the details isexpected as investigation continues. CID, based on the scientific evidences they have collected, claims to have a strong case against the suspects and it’s impossible for them to escape the charges. The case has not only shocked people of Himachal, but also revealed lies and eyewash by administration even in matters as sensitive as quality of drinking water.