Shimla – In the eyes of people of Himachal Pradesh, a peaceful Hill State, the arrival of the Central Bureau of Investigation in Shimla was no less than divine intervention. After all that happened in the gruesome Kotkhai case and the way people lost complete faith in the State Police after mysterious killing of one of the accused, CBI officials are being perceived no less than godly guardians who will rip apart the conspiracy of monsters (real culprits) to deliver justice at every cost, no matter what comes in their way.
It is no co-incident CBI, in its idle form of a law-enforcement agency, is meant to do the same. Moreover, CBI has vowed to crack the case within 10 days, according to a report published in India Today.
But critical, especially journalists point out that CBI officials are human too, and they work under the government. The critics believe they are vulnerable like any other human, but hope it doesn’t turn out to be so in the current case.
There is a reason why CBI officials are being perceived as saviors of justice like incorruptible super cops.
The alleged gang-rape and brutal murder of a 16-years-old school going girl in Shimla’s Kotkhai region is more terrifying than Delhi’s Nirbhaya incident in 2012 if seen from the perspective of delivering justice in its literal sense. Yet, the national media has been discriminate in coverage.
The Police Department in capital Delhi had captured all culprits very swiftly. In Shimla, the police – the law enforcement agency of the State Government – did not work the way it was supposed to, allege family, relatives, and locals in the region.
People are sure the police tried to shield real culprit, who is, they believe, some influential and wealthy person.
In the eyes of common people, the concept of justice was ripped apart with the majority of Himachal alleging Special Investigation Team of HP Police of covering-up real culprits.
It was a huge moral shock for the people of Himachal when they saw pictures of the minor victim’s naked dead body dumped in a pit on social media. The pictures of the girl in the school dress also went viral on social media. In fact, her pictures are still circulating on social media.
But unlike the Delhi’s Nirbhaya case, here people have labeled some other serious allegations. People believe that in order to save the real culprit, the police is trying to sacrifice migrant laborers who have been working in the apple orchards in the same region. This presumption took a concrete form when one of the accused, a Nepalese laborer was killed in the Kothai Police Station in the custody. The police said the accused Raju killed him during a scuffle inside the lock-up of a very small station. The mother of Raju claimed in media statements that Raju and Suraj were like brothers as they lived in the same settlement.
In Kotkhai row, the local police take seven days to arrest six people. In the case of Nirbhaya, the police had convinced, through solid evidences, the entire nation that all arrested men were the real culprits. The police had also managed to keep the identity of the victim undisclosed.
In Shimla, the investigation story isn’t making sense to even uneducated rural population. No men or women with an average level of common sense could find any sense in the investigation and police’s claim that one accused killed another in the security of police.
The wet eyes of victim’s parents, the poverty stricken mother of Raju (accused)left alone after he was arrested in the case, and sobbing wife of another accused Suraj, who was killed in police custody under prototypical circumstances, all have put their faith in the CBI, which is an idle situation.
People believe CBI will unearth the truth and upheld the supremacy of the law. After CBI initiated its probe, the public that had taken to rioting and violence after State government and district administration of Shimla were seen as an accomplice of the alleged real culprit, has calmed down for a while. The anger and distress still exist but CBI has given the public a hope.
The mother of Raju, one of the migrant laborers arrested by the police, appeared on a video clip recorded by a journalist of a Hindi daily. She believes her son was falsely framed. She claimed her son was with her the entire time during which the crime took place as per the police. She is dependent on her son as she is a cancer patient, but now she is left alone, and there is one to take care of her, she says to the journalist.
Similarly, wife of poor Nepalese laborer Suraj appears in videos with two small children. All three were dependent on Suraj.
Now, all desperately wait for CBI to unfold the mystery surrounding the entire case. The justice must be delivered lest people lose faith in the State government and its machinery including law enforcement agencies.
When people no more trust the system and the protection from crimes ensured by it through law, they tend to take the matters into their own hands. People would be running their own trials at their own social and economic levels because they don’t believe the police can get them justice.
No one knows the real story behind the entire crime and investigation is still in progress. The culprits are still to be confirmed, so it would be wrong to draw any conclusion of ours.
But the naked body of the girl dumped in the pit in Kotkhai and the half-naked dead body of the forest guard, Hoshiyar Sing, found hanging upside down from a tree in a forest of Karsog, Mandi, are apt reasons to believe that corruption and prevalence of justice are inversely proportional.
Till we meet again: Shimla Water Crisis
The Honourable Supreme Court in its conclusion to the case Narmada Bachao Andolan Vs Union of India and others on October 18, 2000 states:
Water is the basic need for the survival of human beings and is part of the right of life and human rights as enshrined in Article 21 of the Constitution of India and can be served only by providing a source of water where there is none.
At the time of writing this article, the water crisis in Shimla is effectively over but the fault lines have already been drawn. The crisis placed the beautiful town of Shimla in the global spotlight for all the ugly reasons and highlighted the fissures in this fragile place.
Every source of media whether Indian or Western underscored the problem and compared it to the Cape Town Water crisis. A few went a step further and used the words such as “Day Zero” or “Water Wars” in respect of Shimla without exactly understanding the gravity of the situation and the message the words carry.
Day Zero is when in any town or city the authorities shut off the water supply except hospitals and other vital institution with the majority of residents lining up at water check-points for their daily supply.
Water wars need no introduction except that it takes place between the haves and the have-nots.
All this was done without giving a thought to one’s social responsibility as a citizen or a source of information no matter authentic or apocryphal.
Shimla & Cape Town
Shimla is no Cape Town; it will have to walk several hundred miles to become something even remotely close to it. Cape Town had suffered three years of unprecedented drought, which depleted its water reservoirs supplying water to the city. Due to this, the city had advised its residents to prepare themselves for the purported Day Zero, the year being 2018.
However, before that Cape Town had already embarked on the path for conservation in the year 2007 and had prepared Water Conservation and Water Demand Management Strategy (WC/WDM).
If there existed any prescience in a city in a third world country, then it was Cape Town. Before the introduction of the programme, the water consumption in the city was growing at the rate of 4.7% per annum.
But through its excellent management strategies and innovation Cape Town was able to reduce water consumption growth at a rate of less than 2% per annum. It resulted in a reduction of water wastage by 20% and total water savings of 30% approx.).
For its sustained efforts and successful conservation, Cape Town won first prize for Adaption & Implementation in C40 Cities Award 2015 beating 91 cities including Copenhagen and Paris.
The city did not encourage the tourists to stay away- rather it launched “Save Like a Local Campaign” requesting tourists to keep their water usage to under 87 liters per day, the same restrictions placed on residents. In Cape Town, the Mayor can anytime come knocking at your door to check the water management.
In this city only, the top 100 water user streets were publicised. Water tariffs were structured to cater to poor households. And our intentions are to see ourselves at par with this city, a city that even in times of distress has maintained its dignity.
South Eastern Queensland
Entire Australia suffered drought in the 2000s due to climatic disturbances with South East Queensland being the major casualty. During the beginning of the drought, the per person usage of the Queenslanders was 300 liters per person per day for washing, eating, drinking, and gardening.
Come the year 2015, it was reduced to 169 liters per person per day. Even before the worst phase of drought began in the year 2007, the outdoor water-related restrictions were already in place since 2005.
It was then, that the Queensland Water Commission launched the Target 140 campaign. The campaign emphasized voluntary residential indoor water saving practices, behaviors and attitudes.
The campaign was a success since it achieved a permanent behavioral and attitudinal change. Over a sustained period of eight months of the campaign, the average daily water consumption dropped from 179 liters to 126 liters per person per day.
This change effectively resulted in savings of 20,680 million liters of water.
Life is always full of options, and one such option is “Fight or Flight” and we the people of Shimla choose the flight option when we requested tourists to skip Shimla this summer.
This might have worked for now with tourists staying away from Shimla but this may not work every time. And it will be not long before we realize that such exhortations will strip Shimla of its Soul first and silver later.
We the people of Shimla take pride by seeing ourselves in one of the richest and educated towns in the country. But it is high time, we realize that the next summer is only 300 days away and this crisis is not to be wasted.
We need to learn, how other cities of the world managed to come out of such crises and set examples for the whole world to see. It needs to be ensured that the crisis is not given a rerun the next summer but it will involve drudgery (being primal) on the part of everyone living in Shimla or loving Shimla.
Initially, on the macro level, we need to focus on both the supply side as well as the demand side. First, we should begin with the cheaper solutions i.e. the demand side solutions. The stakeholders in this being residents, hotels, tourists and it can be done by a change in our attitudes. Our behavior and attitudes should reflect the water saving practices which over a period of time become the norm for us.
Incentivising water saving would be the step to go forward on the similar lines of Carbon credits, how about Blue credits. Next would be the supply side solutions, i.e. the costly ones, augmenting the resources catering to Shimla, be it the upcoming Government Schemes or the existing supply schemes.
The city under all circumstances should be prepared for the worst day if it so ever comes.
On a micro level, the dead water or zero revenue water should be reduced, which would effectively mean overhauling the supply systems, so that there are no leakages.
Equipping our buildings with rainwater harvesting systems and similarly incentivising this practice would also go a long way in recharging the groundwater.
Meanwhile, improving the city drainage system would mean that outpouring does not end up in the city sewers. Replacement of the old and antiquated water meters, so that the profligate users are identified and brought to justice.
Taking of Shimla from grey to green by increasing its greenery would ensure that we do not give into concrete. The publishing of Water Report every year, before the onset of summer, outlining water availability in the upcoming months, would ensure that all the stakeholders are made aware in advance of the upcoming water situation.
And all this would begin with a realization of our rights, of our authority and an adage, which goes by Of the People, By the People, For the People, always in the back of our mind.
Water scarcity is here to stay and if there is any chance, it is going to go northwards only.
By Maneet, Shimla
Disclaimer: Himachal Watcher may not share the same views and opinions as expressed by the author in this article.
Why I am resigning from BJP: A data analyst
Political discourse is at it’s lowest point in the country, at least in my lifetime. The partisanship bias is unbelievable and people continue to support their side no matter what the evidence, there is no remorse even when they’re proved to have been spreading fake news. This is something that everyone — the parties and the voters/supporters are to be blamed for.
BJP has done a great job at spreading some specific messages with incredibly effective propaganda, and these messages are the primary reason that I can’t support the party anymore. But before we get into any of that, I’d like everyone to understand that no party is totally bad, and no party is totally good. All governments have done some good and messed up on some fronts. This government is no different.
1. Road construction is faster than it was earlier. There has been a change in the methodology of counting road length, but even factoring that in it seems to be faster.
2. Electricity connection increased
All villages electrified and people getting electricity for more hours. (Congress did electrify over 5 lakh villages and Modi ji finished the job by connecting the last 18k so, you can weigh the achievement as you like. Similarly, the number of hours people get electricity has increased ever since independence, but it might be a larger increase during BJP).
3. Upper-level corruption is reduced
No huge cases at the ministerial level as of now (but the same was true of UPA I :/ ). Lower level seems to be about the same with increased amounts, no one seems to be able to control the thanedar, patwari et al.
4. The Swachh Bharat Mission is a definite success
More toilets built than before and Swachhta is something embedded in people’s minds now.
5. UJJWALA Yojana is a great initiative
How many people buy the second cylinder remains to be seen. The first one and a stove were free, but now people need to pay for it. The cost of cylinders has almost doubled since the government took over and now one costs more than Rs. 800.
6. Connectivity for the North East has undoubtedly increased
More trains, roads, flights and most importantly — the region is now discussed in the mainstream news channels.
7. Law and order is reportedly better than it was under regional parties.
Feel free to add achievements you can think of in the comments below, also achievements necessarily have caveats, failures are absolute!
It takes decades and centuries to build systems and nations, the biggest failure I see in BJP is that it has destroyed some great things on very flimsy grounds.
It basically legalizes corruption and allows corporate & foreign powers to just buy our political parties. The bonds are anonymous so if a corporate says I’ll give you an electoral bond of 1,000 crores if you pass this specific policy, there will be no prosecution. There just is no way to establish quid pro quo with an anonymous instrument. This also explains how corruption is reduced at the Ministerial level — it isn’t per file/order, it is now like the US — at the policy level.
Planning Commission Reports
This used to be a major source for data. They audited government schemes and stated how things are going. With that gone, there just is no choice but to believe whatever data the government gives you (CAG audits come out after a long time!). NITI Aayog doesn’t have this mandate and is basically a think tank and PR agency. Plan/Non-Plan distinction could be removed without removing this!
Misuse of CBI and ED
It is being used for political purposes as far as I can see, but even if it isn’t the fear that these institutions will be unleashed on them if they speak up against anything Modi/Shah related is real. This is enough to kill dissent, an integral component of democracy.
Failure to investigate Kalikho Pul’s suicide note, Judge Loya’s death, Sohrabuddin murder, the defense of an MLA accused of Rape who’s relative is accused of killing the girl’s father and FIR wasn’t registered for over a year..!
It failed, but worse is BJP’s inability to accept that it failed. All propaganda of it cutting terror funding, reducing cash, eliminating corruption is just absurd. It also killed off businesses.
Implemented in a hurry and harmed business. Complicated structure, multiple rates on different items, complex filing… Hopefully, it’ll stabilize in time, but it did cause harm. Failure to acknowledge that from BJP is extremely arrogant.
The messed up foreign policy with pure grandstanding
China has a port in Sri Lanka, huge interests in Bangladesh and Pakistan — we’re surrounded, the failure in Maldives (Indian workers not getting visas anymore because of India’s foreign policy debacle) while Modi Ji goes out to foreign countries and keeps saying Indians had no respect in the world before 2014 and now they’re supremely respected (This is nonsense. Indian respect in foreign countries was a direct result of our growing economy and IT sector, it hasn’t improved an ounce because of Modi. Might even have declined due to beef based lynchings, threats to journalists etc.)
Failure of schemes and failure to acknowledge/course correct
Sansad Adarsh Gram Yojana, Make In India, Skill Development, Fasal Bima (look at reimbursements — the government is lining the pockets of insurance companies). Failure to acknowledge unemployment and farmers crisis — calling every real issue an opposition stunt.
The high prices of Petrol and Diesel
Modi Ji and all BJP ministers + supporters criticized Congress for it heavily and now all of them justify the high prices even though crude is cheaper than it was then! Just unacceptable.
Failure to engage with the most important basic issues
Education and Healthcare. There is just nothing on education which is the nation’s biggest failure. Quality of government schools has deteriorated over the decades (ASER reports) and no action. They did nothing on Healthcare for 4 years, then Ayushman Bharat was announced — that scheme scares me more than nothing being done. Insurance schemes have a terrible track record and this is going the US route, which is a terrible destination for healthcare (watch Sicko by Michael Moore)!
You can add some and subtract some based on personal understanding of the issue, but this is my assessment. The Electoral Bonds thing is huge and hopefully, the SC will strike it down! Every government has some failures and some bad decisions though, the bigger issue I have is more on morals than anything else.
The real negative of this government is how it has affected the national discourse with a well-considered strategy. This isn’t a failure, it’s the plan.
It has discredited the media, so now every criticism is brushed off as a journalist who didn’t get paid by BJP or is on the payrolls of Congress. I know several journalists for whom the allegation can’t be true, but more importantly, no one ever addresses the accusation or complaint — they just attack the person raising the issue and ignore the issue itself.
It has peddled a narrative that nothing happened in India in 70 years.
This is patently false and the mentality is harmful to the nation. This government spent over Rs. 4,000 crore of our taxpayer money on advertisements and now that will become the trend. Do small works and huge branding. He isn’t the first one to build roads — some of the best roads I’ve traveled on were pet projects of Mayawati and Akhilesh Yadav. India became an IT powerhouse from the 90s. It is easy to measure past performance and berate past leaders based on the circumstances of today, just one example of that:
Why did Congress not build toilets in 70 years?
They couldn’t even do something so basic. This argument sounds logical and I believed it too, until I started reading India’s history. When we gained independence in 1947 we were an extremely poor country, we didn’t have the resources for even basic infrastructure and no capital. To counteract this PM Nehru went down the socialist path and created PSU’s. We had no capacity to build steel, so with the help of Russians the Heavy Engineering Corporation (HEC), Ranchi was set up that made machines to make steel in India — without this we would have no steel, and consequently no infrastructure.
That was the agenda — basic industries and infra. We had frequent droughts (aakaal), every 2–3 years and a large number of people starved to death. The priority was to feed the people, toilets were a luxury no one cared for. The Green Revolution happened and the food shortages disappeared by the 1990s — now we have a surplus problem. The toilet situation is exactly like people asking 25 years from now why Modi couldn’t make all houses in India air conditioned. That seems like a luxury today, toilets were also a luxury at some point of time. Maybe things could have happened sooner, maybe 10–15 years ago, but nothing happened in 70 years is a horrible lie to peddle.
3. The spread and reliance on Fake News
There is some anti-BJP fake news too, but the pro-BJP and anti-opposition fake news outstrips that by miles in number and in reach. Some of it is supporters, but a lot of it comes from the party. It is often hateful and polarizing, which makes it even worse. The online news portals backed by this government are damaging society more than we know.
4. Hindu Khatre Mein Hain
They’ve ingrained it into the minds of people that Hindus and Hinduism are in danger, and that Modi is the only option to save ourselves. In reality Hindus have been living the same lives much before this government and nothing has changed except people’s mindset. Were we Hindus in danger in 2007? At least I didn’t hear about it everyday and I see no improvement in the condition of Hindus, just more fear mongering and hatred.
5. Speak against the government and you’re anti-National and more recently, anti-Hindu
Legitimate criticism of the government is shut up with this labeling. Prove your nationalism, sing Vande Mataram everywhere (even though BJP leaders don’t know the words themselves, they’ll force you to sing it!). I’m a proud nationalist and my nationalism won’t allow me to let anyone force me to showcase it! I will sing the national anthem and national song with pride when the occasion calls for it, or when I feel like it, but I won’t let anyone force me to sing it based on their whims!
6. Running news channels that are owned by BJP leaders who’s sole job is to debate Hindu-Muslim, National-Antinational, India-Pakistan and derail the public discourse from issues and logic into polarizing emotions. You all know exactly which ones, and you all even know the debaters who’re being rewarded for spewing the vilest propaganda.
7. The polarization
The message of development is gone. BJP’s strategy for the next election is polarization and inciting pseudo-nationalism. Modi ji has basically said it himself in speeches — Jinnah; Nehru; Congress leaders didn’t meet Bhagat Singh in jail (fake news from the PM himself!); INC leaders met leaders in Pakistan to defeat Modi in Gujarat; Yogi ji’s speech on how Maharana Pratap was greater than Akbar; JNU students are anti-national they’ll #TukdeTukdeChurChur India — this is all propaganda constructed for a very specific purpose — polarize and win elections — it isn’t the stuff I want to be hearing from my leaders and I refuse to follow anyone who is willing to let the nation burn in riots for political gain.
These are just some of the instances of how BJP is pushing the national discourse in a dark corner. This isn’t something I signed up for and it totally isn’t something I can support. That is why I am resigning from BJP.
PS: I supported BJP since 2013 because Narendra Modi Ji seemed like a ray of hope for India and I believed in his message of development — that message and the hope are now both gone. The negatives of this Narendra Modi and Amit Shah government now outweigh the positives for me, but that is a decision that every voter needs to make individually. Just know that history and reality are complicated. Buying into simplistic propaganda and espousing cult-like unquestioning faith are the worst thing you can do — it is against the interests of democracy and of this nation.
You all have your own decisions to make as the elections approach. Best of luck with that. My only hope is that we can all live and work harmoniously together — and contribute towards making a better, stronger, poverty-free and developed India, no matter what party or ideology we support. Always remember that there are good people on both sides, the voter needs to support them and they need to support each other even when they are in different parties.
By Shivam Shankar Singh – The author is a former-data analytics for the BJP’s poll campaigns.
Disclaimer: The blog has been re-published with permission of the author and without much editing. The opinion expressed in it does not necessarily reflect Himachal Watcher’s point of view.
HP Polls 2017: Shimla Urban may decide flow of wind
Harish is his limited area from Sanjauli to Mall Road. Whereas Harbhajan Singh Bhajji has a considerable clout in all areas of the constituency,
Shimla: The elections to the Legislative Assembly of Himachal Pradesh are inching closer with each passing day and it’s only two days for the fate of all political parties to be sealed in the electronic voting machines.
In this elections, Shimla Urban is a seat that none of the political parties – be it Congress or BJP would like to lose. The major fight remains between Suresh Bhardwaj of BJP and Harbhajan Singh Bhajji of Congress.
Just wait, let me correct as there are two more faces that are influential and will be vying for the seat on November 9, 2017: Sanjay Chauhan and Harish Janartha. However, what impact would they have on the political calculations for this most coveted assembly seat remains to be seen.
As Suresh Bhardwaj is struggling hard with the anti-incumbency factor owing to demonetization and GST implementation, Harbhajan Singh Bhajji can score higher here.
Suresh Bhardwaj is the sitting MLA and aims to win Shimla Urban third time in a row. He has already defeated Harbhajan Singh Bhajji in 1990 elections.
Whereas Harbhajan Singh Bhajji, who had represented Shimla Urban two times, wouldn’t leave anything on fate to prove his metal and make the most out of the opportunity.
As already said, two more candidates are in the fray who have a considerable chunk of the vote bank, but are marred by their own undoing.
Whereas, Sanjay Chauhan’s term as the mayor of Shimla MC was engulfed with major issues like the water shortage, jaundice and garbage collection problem, Harish Janartha is expelled from the party and is questioned for not being loyal to the party that included him in the government even when he lost the last election.
Besides this, what confines Harish is his limited area from Sanjauli to Mall Road. Whereas Harbhajan Singh Bhajji has a considerable clout in all areas of the constituency, which could be a determining factor.
By Vinod Sharma
Disclaimer: Views expressed in the article are entirely of the author, and do not necessarily reflect opinion of Himachal Watcher
HIMCOSTE PLS: Eminent scientist & activist Dr Vandana Shiva to speak at Shimla on July 17
Shimla Police nabs Nigerian man with 25 grams Chitta
15 lakh saplings planted in Himachal by 80,000 people in 3 days, claims Forest Minister
Gunfight in Naina Devi: One wanted criminal shot dead, 2 arrested
Centre approves DPR preparation for 58 NHs in Himachal: HP Govt
Gunfight in Naina Devi: One wanted criminal shot dead, 2 arrested
Nauni varsity’s UG entrance exam results declared
Meet Himachal’s Virender who bagged silver for India in his first international boxing tournament
HP. Treasury asks pensioners to submit Life Certificate by July 1, 2018
Story of Shimla youth who started with smoking charas at 17, ended up in jail at 22 as drug peddler
Misc News/Press Release2 days ago
Gunfight in Naina Devi: One wanted criminal shot dead, 2 arrested
Misc News/Press Release2 months ago
HP Cabinet Decisions May 2018: Govt to fill up 333 posts in HP NHM, relax conditions for full pension, launch 2 schemes
Misc News/Press Release2 months ago
Himachal’s Dr Vivek Bindal performs India’s first robotic surgery on 14-year-old
Misc News/Press Release2 months ago
HP Govt’s Jan Manch programme for on spot grievance redressal to be launched on 26 May
Misc News/Press Release2 months ago
British-era Bantony Castle Shimla to become Rs. 25 crore cultural centre
Misc News/Press Release1 month ago
No more water-shortage in hotels of Shimla, Govt and hoteliers assure tourists
HW Community2 months ago
Worsening water crisis of Shimla town now reminds Govt about water-conservation
Campus Watch1 month ago
76 Nauni Varsity students qualify ICAR NET this year