Connect with us

HW Community

Strongest lead in Shimla’s Gudiya rape & murder case

Published

on

Strongest lead in the Shimla Gangrape and murder case

Isn’t the identification of the motive behind the conspiracy strongest lead for the CBI? Didn’t CBI ask Negi why he lodged a fake FIR? What about the CM Virbhadra Singh’s IT Cell?

Shimla: To the disappointment of the people of Himachal who had pinned their hopes on the Central Bureau of Investigation, and were awaiting justice for Gudiya of Shimla’s Kotkhai region, the agency’s Special Investigation Team (SIT) submitted its seventh incomplete report in the Himachal Pradesh High Court on December 20, 2017. 

The agency could not make any headway and demanded more time.  The CBI said it has collected DNA samples of some other persons, and the forensic investigation would take more time. 

However, the agency failed to explain how much time it would need to investigate the case.

The division bench of the acting Chief Justice Sanjay Karol and Justice Sandeep Sharma pulled up the CBI SIT and summoned the Director of CBI asking him to file an affidavit in the case. 

The court inquired why the Director did not intervene despite being aware of the situation.  The matter is associated with the sentiments of the people, which makes it a highly sensitive case, said the Court.  The court also told the CBI to employ more teams to solve the case if required.

The CBI had been assuring the Court every time it filed a status report that it was making progress in the investigation. Since July 22 – the day on which the CBI had filed two separate FIRs in rape and murder case and custodial death of an arrested accused Suraj Singh (29)- the CBI did not give even a slight sign that it has no clue about the real culprits.

Now, after an extensive investigation of over five months, the CBI team says it is a case of blind murder and the forensic and other physical evidences were washed away by the rain, which is why the agency was not able to find and arrest the real culprits, who remain unknown after six months since the discovery of the naked dead body of the minor victim on July 6.

It was during the last week that the CBI announced a reward of meagre Rs. 10 lakh to anyone from the public who would provide credible information regarding the actual criminals. 

 The agency did an appreciable job by cracking the case relating to the alleged custodial killing of the accused Suraj at the Police station of Kotkhai.

It is possible that the police messed up the evidences so badly that the CBI is actually finding it hard to trace the real culprits. However, they still have a strong lead that could lead to the real criminals – the motive of the local police behind this conspiracy. 

In its charge-sheet against the accused police officials, who are currently lodged at the Model Central Jail, Kanda, the agency said the Police SIT formed by the Director General of Police, Somesh Goyal, framed wrong persons without any substantial evidence, inflicted severe physical torture to extract false confession, and, in doing so, allegedly hacked one of them to death on the intervening night of July 18 and 19.

The CBI has assured the court that it is in possession of clinching pieces of evidence to prove the allegations made against the accused cops in the charge-sheet.

Interestingly, the CBI’s charge-sheet has perhaps skipped the identification of the motive behind this conspiracy of the local police. The CBI says it doesn’t have much evidence that could lead to the arrest of the real offenders.

The CBI’s chargesheet says the police SIT allegedly tempered with the forensic evidences to such an extent that it has become extremely difficult to trace the real culprits. It implies these cops are responsible for saving the real culprits.   

However, we wonder why the CBI doesn’t ask the accused cops why they did it.

Such a cover-up can’t be for a recreational activity for sure? Isn’t the identification of the motive behind the conspiracy the strongest lead for the CBI? 

Further, why the IT Cell of then Chief Minister Virbhadra Singh was grilled and questioned about the photos it had shared and deleted on the Facebook page?

The police allegedly abducted and hacked a man to death without any evidence, so why not to give third degree to the arrested cops including Zahur H. Zaidi, then Inspector General of the Police and head of the SIT and DW Negi, then Superintendent of Police, Shimla, to extract the motive behind this heinous conspiracy. 

The CBI had told the court that DW Negi was involved in the conspiracy and lodged a fake FIR to frame Raju, prime accused, for the killing of Suraj inside the lock-up. Didn’t CBI ask Negi why he did it? 

HW Community

“Are IG, SP, DSP in jail to save a woodcutter?”: Unconvinced father of Gudiya asks CBI

Published

on

CBI Probe in Kotkhai case

If the police officials did not try to shield anyone, then they must have done it either for medals or under an extreme political pressure ahead of assembly elections.

Shimla: The findings of the Central Bureau of Investigation in the Gudiya case, which had sparked massive protests in Shimla, did not sound convincing to the parents of the victim and a section of the locals.

The father told media that though he has full faith in the CBI, he is not convinced that a 4-feet man empowered a 16-year-old alone and raped her in the forest.

In addition, the CBI did not explain where did the accused keep her for one and a half day. As per the CBI, the accused committed the crime on the evening of July 4, but her body was found on the morning of July 6, the father added.

They had launched an extensive search in the forests on July 5, however, did not come across the body of the victim, the father told media.

For the father, more bewildering is the fact that three high-rank officials are in jail with six others just to save a woodcutter.

It is a point that is creating confusion among the locals, who have followed the series of events in the case. The CBI never spoke of the motive of the arrested police officials.

If the CBI has conducted a fair probe, then what was the motive of the police officials behind framing innocent men and allegedly kill one of them in custody in order to extract a false confession, he asked.

If the police officials did not try to shield anyone, then they must have done it either for medals or under an extreme political pressure ahead of assembly elections which were just a couple of months away, the locals are speculating.  

However, the Congress party, which was in power when the incident took place, is convinced with the probe and have appreciated the agency for cracking the case.  The party had on April 25 released a media statement regarding the same. 

Further, the father, in his statements to the media, asked why the clothes of the victim were not damaged if the crime was committed in the forest by over-powering her. Her clothes, the father said, were placed by her body like it was done deliberately and carefully.  

He also said that the CBI did not inform them regarding the status of the case even after claiming to have solved the case.

The parents said they would knock at the doors of the court if the CBI fails to complete the missing parts of the entire episode and answer their questions.

At the same time, a section of the people believes that the CBI might have actually caught the actual accused. However, the gaps in the CBI theory are bothering most of the people.

The CBI, on the other hand, said the investigation would continue and, meanwhile, a charge-sheet would be filed against the accused within the stipulated period of 90 days.

However, at the same time, the agency had yesterday told the court that it is filing its last status report in the case.

The CBI needs to fill the gaps in its story to convince the parents and the locals.

Hopefully, with the filing of the charge-sheet, more facts would emerge to verify the CBI probe.

Because, in the absence of it, the people have already begun to term the arrested accused a scapegoat that the agency used to save itself and its Chief from embarrassment.

Continue Reading

HW Community

Kotkhai Gudiya case solved, says CBI claiming it was not a gang rape

Published

on

Kotkhai gudiya case solved says cbi

Shimla: In yet another mind-boggling development in the Gudiya case, the Central Bureau of Investigation today, while submitting its status report in the Himachal Pradesh High Court, reportedly claimed that it has cracked the case.

The CBI told the court that it was the last status report in the case and that it would file a charge-sheet against the accused within 90 days.

The news has begun to appear in national media where it is being claimed that the agency has finally cracked the blind case of rape and murder.

The PTI reported that the CBI has changed the theory given by the local police and claimed that it was not a case of gangrape. As per CBI, the lone accused, who was identified as Anil Kumar, has been arrested on April 13 based on the DNA reports that matched with the sample taken from victim’s body. The accused was said to be a lumberjack.

The report further said the CBI had found that the accused had been hiding all this time and that he also has a criminal background.

The agency used new DNA percentage matches and lineage matches to crack the case. The agency further claimed that it was after getting multiple scientific pieces of evidence that the accused was identified and arrested.

The investigation was done quietly and away from public scrutiny to ensure culprits don’t escape. Accused was arrested on 13 April and produced before designated Court today. He has been remanded to judicial custody till 7 May,

Abhishek Dayal, CBI Chief Info Officer, told ANI.

However, the court was not satisfied with the status report and asked the agency to file an affidavit on the behalf of its Director.

The next hearing will be conducted on May 8. The court said it would decide whether the CBI Chief to be summoned or not. The CBI defended its Director saying he had been carefully monitoring all the status reports filed in the court.

The CBI counsel tried to convince the court that there was no need to direct the Director to be personally present in the court.

The people of Himachal are bewildered as nine police officials including then Inspector General Zahur H Zaidi, SP of Shimla, DW Negi, and DSP of Theog, Manoj Joshi, were put behind bars by the agency on August 29, 2017.

The CBI charge-sheet filed against the nine police officials alleged the accused of hatching a conspiracy, framing wrong people, and even hacking one of them to death in police custody.

The people believed that some influential and wealthy people influenced the police probe to shield the real culprits. There have been rioting like the situation in Kotkhai region and entire Himachal was echoing with protesting voices. However, now a big question that arises here is that why did local police take such a risk? How can a simple lumberjack influence police SIT and fool the CBI for 10 months?

The reactions of the victim’s parents and locals towards the CBI probe are still awaited. Moreover, in coming days, the agency may come out with a public statement to explain the entire episode and clear the doubts of the people regarding the investigation.

Continue Reading

HW Community

Road in Mashobra Ward of SMC in tatters for last 10 years

Published

on

Road-in-Shimla-MC-Ward-21

Shimla: While the new Government of Himachal Pradesh claims that it has achieved all the targets it had set for the first 100 days, the ground reality doesn’t agree with it entirely.

As per the Chief Minister Jai Ram Thakur, Rs. 100 crores were sanctioned for repair and maintenance of roads, however, even the urban Shimla did not witness these repairs.

Some residents of Mashobra – Lower Dhalli Ward (Number 21) of the Shimla Municipal Corporation wrote to Himachal Watcher regarding the pathetic condition of the road in their locality algonwith pictures of the Mashobra market.  

The road has not been repaired from last 10 years. The problem of water-logging pertains from past 5 years, but the civic body did not attend to it, 

said one of the residents.

Bhartiya Janata Party’s Shalinder Chauhan has been elected for the second time as councillor of the Ward. However, he made only promises to solve this problem, which were never fulfilled,

the resident further added.

Mashobra market

This road leads to famous tourist destinations like Talai, Carignano Nature Park along with government offices like the Regional Horticultural Research Station, Mashobra, and HP Panchayati Raj Training Institute.

Despite the frequent movement of government officials in this Ward, the road did not attract the attention of any single of them.

Several Ministers cross this road and, a few days back, the Akhil Bhartiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) had organized a national level annual meeting near Talai, but the problem remains invisible to everyone except the locals,

a local youth told HW.

The pedestrians face daily trouble due to the large potholes, which turn into pools of water when it rains. Passing vehicles splash accumulated water on pedestrians. During sunny days, clouds of dust troubles the residents as well as shopkeepers and dhabs located in the market, the residents complained.   

The locals are forced to live in dust and mud for last 10 years, but the problems of the locals did not find a place in media, they further complained.

Continue Reading

Trending